Results for assoc.test.sh

status	bash	osh
pass	21	23
ok	0	2
N-I	0	2
BUG	7	0
FAIL	0	1
total	28	28

case	bash	osh	description
0	pass	pass	Literal syntax ([x]=y)
1	BUG	pass	set associative array to indexed array literal (very surprising bash behavior)
	details
2	BUG	pass	Can't initialize assoc array with indexed array
	details
3	BUG	pass	Initializing indexed array with assoc array
	details
4	pass	pass	create empty assoc array, put, then get
5	pass	pass	retrieve keys with !
6	pass	pass	retrieve values with ${A[@]}
7	pass	FAIL	coerce to string with ${A[*]}, etc.
		details
8	pass	pass	${A[@]/b/B}
9	pass	pass	${A[@]#prefix}
10	pass	ok	${assoc} disallowed in OSH, like ${assoc[0]} in bash
		details
11	pass	pass	length ${#a[@]}
12	pass	pass	lookup with ${a[0]} -- "0" is a string
13	pass	pass	lookup with double quoted strings "mykey"
14	pass	pass	lookup with single quoted string
15	pass	pass	lookup with unquoted $key and quoted "$i$i"
16	BUG	pass	lookup by unquoted string doesn't work in OSH because it's a variable
	details
17	BUG	pass	bash bug: "i+1" and i+1 are the same key
	details
18	pass	pass	Array stored in associative array gets converted to string (without strict-array)
19	pass	pass	Indexed array as key of associative array coerces to string (without shopt -s strict-array)
20	pass	pass	Append to associative array value A['x']+='suffix'
21	BUG	pass	Slice of associative array doesn't make sense in bash
	details
22	pass	N-I	bash variable can have an associative array part and a string part
		details
23	pass	N-I	Associative array expressions inside (( )) with keys that look like numbers
		details
24	pass	pass	(( A[5] += 42 ))
25	pass	pass	(( A[5] += 42 )) with empty cell
26	BUG	pass	setting key to itself (from bash-bug mailing list)
	details
27	pass	ok	readonly associative array can't be modified
		details

44 passed, 2 OK, 2 not implemented, 7 BUG, 1 failed, 0 timeouts, 0 cases skipped
1 failed under osh

Details on runs that didn't PASS

bash	1 set associative array to indexed array literal (very surprising bash behavior) stdout: foo spam eggs k1 k2 [] [] stderr: /home/andy/git/oilshell/oil/_tmp/spec-bin/bash: line 4: assoc: foo: must use subscript when assigning associative array /home/andy/git/oilshell/oil/_tmp/spec-bin/bash: line 4: assoc: 'spam eggs': must use subscript when assigning associative array
bash	2 Can't initialize assoc array with indexed array stdout: status=0 stderr: /home/andy/git/oilshell/oil/_tmp/spec-bin/bash: line 1: A: 1: must use subscript when assigning associative array /home/andy/git/oilshell/oil/_tmp/spec-bin/bash: line 1: A: 2: must use subscript when assigning associative array /home/andy/git/oilshell/oil/_tmp/spec-bin/bash: line 1: A: 3: must use subscript when assigning associative array
bash	3 Initializing indexed array with assoc array stdout: status=0 ['3'] stderr:
osh	7 coerce to string with ${A[]}, etc. [osh stdout] Expected "['xx yy']\n['X X Y Y']\n['xx', 'yy']\n['X', 'X', 'Y', 'Y']\n", got "['xx', 'yy']\n['X X Y Y']\n['xx', 'yy']\n['X', 'X', 'Y', 'Y']\n" stdout:* ['xx', 'yy'] ['X X Y Y'] ['xx', 'yy'] ['X', 'X', 'Y', 'Y'] stderr:
osh	10 ${assoc} disallowed in OSH, like ${assoc[0]} in bash stdout: stderr: echo "${a}" ^~ [ stdin ]:3: fatal: Array 'a' can't be referred to as a scalar (without @ or *)
bash	16 lookup by unquoted string doesn't work in OSH because it's a variable stdout: c stderr:
bash	17 bash bug: "i+1" and i+1 are the same key stdout: array[i]=6 array[i+1]=7 assoc[i]=string assoc[i+1]=string+1 assoc[i]=string assoc[i+1]=string+1 stderr:
bash	21 Slice of associative array doesn't make sense in bash stdout: ['2', '1', '5'] ['2', '1', '5'] ['1', '5', '4'] ['5', '4', '3'] ['4', '3'] ['3'] stderr:
osh	22 bash variable can have an associative array part and a string part stdout: stderr: echo ${assoc[1]} ${assoc[2]} ${assoc} ^~ [ stdin ]:4: fatal: Array 'assoc' can't be referred to as a scalar (without @ or *)
osh	23 Associative array expressions inside (( )) with keys that look like numbers stdout: 42 stderr: (( var = assoc[0] )) ^~ [ stdin ]:5: fatal: Can't evaluate associative arrays in arithmetic contexts
bash	26 setting key to itself (from bash-bug mailing list) stdout: value1 value2 stderr:
osh	27 readonly associative array can't be modified stdout: stderr: A['x']=1 ^~ [ stdin ]:2: fatal: Can't assign to readonly associative array